|
Are We Worried Yet?
A 2020 Pew Research study reveals that over half of white, liberal women have
been diagnosed with a mental health condition at some point. Does this mean
there's a correlation between progressive ideas and mental health?
It's a common tactic of the politically charged on either side (and normally
perceived as a cheap one at that) to take the particular adherents of an
ideology and equate that diehard worship to mental illness.
Conservatives label younger liberal generations as snowflakes or as having
Trump derangement syndrome if they didn't like the past president; liberals and
progressives label right-leaning individuals or conservatives as racists,
bigots, misogynists, etc. Resorting to this type of lowbrow behavior might once
have been seen as an excuse not to address the actual issues or beliefs at
hand, but now ad hominem attacks are more common than not.
But what if what was once a cheap shot or a personal insult has actually been
found to bear scientific correlation between the individuals who hold
progressive ideologies and an increased risk of mental illness? That's exactly
what Pew Research has found - and all politics aside, the shocking diagnosis of
over 50% of liberal women with some form of mental health medical diagnosis is
a public health concern that no one seems to be discussing, let alone taking
seriously.
Women and Mental Illness
For whatever reason, we're not talking about the risk of mental illness women
in general face, especially compared to men.
Women are 40% more likely to develop depression than men. Due to lower levels
of serotonin, we're also more likely to have anxiety and depression because of
that deficiency. There are also certain life experiences, like childbirth for
example, which can lead to these diagnoses. 1 in 7 women will be diagnosed with
postpartum depression in the year following childbirth. Postpartum depression
in particular is a condition that leaves its victims feeling powerless and
without confidence or assurance in their own abilities as a mom or caregiver -
many women with postpartum depression describe feeling like failures.
Women are 40% more likely to develop depression than men.
Conditions like depression and anxiety thrive in silence, but there also seems
to be a lack of confidence in women when it comes to knowing our own bodies,
and instead our mental problems are written off as being too overly
"emotional." (Think about how many times someone has described you or another
woman as emotional.) While hormones do obviously play a role in the development
of mental health, for better or for worse, it's possible to minimize or
downplay the risks our mental health is facing if they're written off as a
"hormonal" issue, whether it's our medical professionals or even ourselves
engaging in that mindset.
But biology and hormones aside, what about the choices we actively engage in?
The behaviors we indulge, the beliefs and convictions we hold as more important
than all the others? The people we spend our time with, the actions we devote
our energy to, and the news we consume? Is that negatively impacting our mental
health, or even more importantly, leading to medical diagnoses?
Here's What the Study Found
The study in question - which, by the way, isn't from a news source or media
outlet but Pew Research for heaven's sake - is, when all's said and done,
pretty damning.
Interestingly enough, the study, which is titled Pew American Trends Panel:
Wave 64, was dated March 2020 - over a year ago. Yet it took a Ph.D. candidate
in political science posting about the study on Twitter for it to garner even a
smidge of attention.
The study, which examined white liberals, moderates, and conservatives, both
male and female, found that conservatives were far less likely to be diagnosed
with mental health issues than those who identified as either liberal or even
"very liberal." What's more, white women suffered the worst of all. White
women, ages 18-29, who identified as liberal were given a mental health
diagnosis from medical professionals at a rate of 56.3%, as compared to 28.4%
in moderates and 27.3% in conservatives.
conservative liberal women mental health graph pew research
Zach Goldberg, the doctoral candidate in question, consolidated the study's
info in a set of visuals and posted them to a thread on Twitter. But it's
important to note that he clarified the following: "I didn't write this thread
to mock white liberals or their apparently disproportionate rates of mental
illness (and you shouldn't either). Rather, this is a question that's
underexplored and which may shed light on attitudinal differences towards
various social policies." He's right.
Dr. Lyle Rossiter, a board-certified psychiatrist who's treated mental
disorders for over 30 years, agrees and adds that white liberalism thrives on
supposedly championing "workers," "minorities," "the little guy," "women," and
the "unemployed," who they continuously see as "wronged, cheated, oppressed,
disenfranchised, exploited, and victimized" with little to no agency of their
own (A view that often mutates into the infantilizing and patronizing of
certain groups within a narrative).
When those raised to think reality is subjective bump up against objective
reality, there can be mental health consequences.
The people responsible for these crimes? As Rossiter tells it: "poverty,
disease, war, ignorance, unemployment, racial prejudice, ethnic and gender
discrimination, modern technology, capitalism, globalization, and imperialism.
In the radical liberal mind, this suffering is inflicted on the innocent by
various predators and persecutors: 'Big Business,' 'Big Corporations,' 'greedy
capitalists,' 'U.S. Imperialists,' 'the oppressors,' 'the rich,' 'the
wealthy,' 'the powerful,' and 'the selfish'."
That's pretty much an exhaustive list of every grievance and every perpetrator
that progressives see as responsible for these injustices which plague our
disenfranchised communities while moderates and conservatives seemingly sit
idly by unconcerned with anything but their own privilege.
But as the study exemplifies, the champions of these causes (white women in
particular) aren't exactly living the liberated utopia they believe we all
should be living.
Taking It Seriously
It's truly unfortunate that so many women are facing these kinds of issues, and
that this prevalence of mental illness among progressive women might be being
weaponized for political purposes. If there's one thing this topic deserves,
it's delicacy and empathy. We should feel compassion for these women,
especially if we've struggled with mental health ourselves.
But at the heart of the matter is this: Progressivism is an ideology that
supposedly demands equality for all, and one that keeps score to an exhausting
degree. The privilege between social classes, between races, between men and
women, between religious and non-religious, and more, all have to be constantly
monitored, and "inequality" has to be exposed for the purposes of
"accountability." That kind of behavior isn't just unrealistic, it's
unsustainable. In all honesty, it's understandable that anxiety and depression
thrive in these kinds of environments when we're focusing on every minute,
problematic issue in our world and not able to take comprehensive, productive
action to solve all these problems.
Progressivism demands equality for all and keeps score to an exhausting,
unsustainable degree.
There's also the unrelenting focus on oppression, verbal violence, and micro-
aggressions. We know that building resiliency against hardship is the best
weapon against depression and anxiety, yet progressive ideology forces its
followers to wallow in feelings of helplessness and victimhood. Instead of
empowering women and minorities with self-knowledge, strength of character, and
resilience to hardship, progressivism encourages victims to stay in a place of
fear and helplessness.
Closing Thoughts
It's not just significant that the women suffering from mental health issues
are white (though we'll get to that) but especially that they're so young. The
age range of those most affected was 18-29. These women are students,
employees, moms, daughters, wives, and friends. They have goals and ambitions,
yet who knows how hampered their day-to-day lives are by the conditions they've
been diagnosed with.
But it's also key that white individuals are usually at the forefront of these
movements, whether or not they're the group being adversely affected. As most
of us know by now, white guilt and savior narratives are pretty much as bad as
any genuinely racist agenda because it robs the very group they're trying to
help of their own voice.
We should be having the difficult conversations this topic requires. But if you
take a quick look at the state of our political discourse nowadays, we might
not be ready for it.
|
White Women Under 30 Have A Mental Health Issue [re: Mod vege]
(старо куче)
